"Show other people if I run out" is a setting in Bumble's basic filters. With it on, once you have seen everyone who fits your filters, Bumble may start showing you people outside them to help you make more connections. With it off, you only see women who fit, so the deck can run out.
Where the setting lives
It sits in the basic filters, the same filters screen you open by tapping the filters icon in the top right of the People tab. The basic filters are the ones every account gets. They cover age, verification, languages and shared interests, and distance in the countries where Bumble offers it. In the US and Canada there are ethnicity preferences too.
The setting does not replace any of those. It only decides what happens after you have worked through everyone they allow.
What changes when it is on
Nothing changes until you reach the end of the women who fit. Up to that point your deck looks exactly as it did before.
After that point, Bumble may widen things on your behalf. Its help page says it may show you people outside your filters, and it does not spell out which filters it relaxes or by how much. So assume any of them could be crossed. A woman a little older than your range. Someone farther away than your distance setting.
Notice the word "may," too. Turning it on does not promise an endless deck. It means Bumble can reach past your filters when it has nothing left inside them.
Preferences versus dealbreakers
Whether to use it comes down to what your filters really are.
Some are preferences. You set 25 to 32 because it felt about right, but a sharp, funny 34 year old would not bother you at all. For settings like that, this option is a free widening. You keep your ideal range at the front and get extra choices only once it runs out.
Others are dealbreakers. If you have kids and set an age floor because you want a woman at the same stage of life, crossing it does you no favors. For settings like that, leave the option off and widen something else instead.
A good test is to picture the best woman you could hope to see in your deck, then change one detail about her. Make her two years outside your range, or twenty minutes farther out than your distance setting. If you would still swipe right on her, that filter is a preference.
Most men have a mix of both, which is the honest reason to review your filters one at a time rather than flipping a single switch and hoping.
Swiping on the people outside your filters
When the deck starts showing people past your filters, it is easy to swipe on autopilot, because you know these are the extras.
Treat each one as a real person. Look past the first photo, read what she wrote, and check where she is. A woman outside your distance setting might live across town, or she might live two hours away. That changes whether a first drink is realistic, so work it out before you swipe right rather than after you match.
a dating coach has a simple view of the apps: who you choose to swipe right on decides who you end up talking to. That does not change because the app widened the net for you.
Treat those matches like any other
A match that came from outside your filters is still a match. Open the conversation the same way you would with anyone else, and move toward a plan at the same pace.
The only difference is logistics. If she is farther away than you usually go, say so early. My rule for a first date is to hold it near your place if you can and near hers if you cannot, never somewhere in the middle. Distance makes that rule matter more, because a halfway spot leaves neither of you close to home when the evening is going well.
Be honest with yourself before you match, too. If she is an hour away and you already know you will not make that drive on a weeknight, pass and save you both the conversation. If she is an hour away and clearly worth it, say so, and suggest a Saturday when the drive does not matter.
When the deck runs dry every week
If you keep hitting the point where this setting kicks in, the setting is telling you something. Your filters are tighter than your city can support.
Bumble's own tip for this is to relax your filters, since even small changes to age or distance can bring in compatible people you would otherwise have missed. Do that on purpose. Choose which range to widen and by how much, instead of letting the app pick for you at the edges.
Think of this setting as a backstop. It is useful on the nights you would otherwise see nothing. It is not a substitute for filters that fit where you live.
Written by Matthew Stevens, Co-Founder & Head Coach. More than half a decade coaching men across the US and worldwide.
Everything here comes out of real coaching work: the approaches, dates, texts and profiles we go through with the men we coach.