Four stand out. A match who wants to leave the app within a few messages. Anyone who mentions money, a cause or an investment. Someone who avoids every plan to meet. And a woman who is very warm, very fast and very vague. Hinge's own guidance names the first two, and the rest come from how real chats go wrong.
Moving you off the app early
Hinge tells its members to be wary of anyone who steers the chat to another app too soon. It is the most common first step in a scam.
A woman who asks for your number or another messaging app in the first few exchanges is not always a fake. Plenty of real women do it once they are comfortable. What matters is the speed and the reason. "My Hinge notifications are broken" on day one, plus a request to move to an app you have never used, is a sign worth stopping on.
Take your time. A real woman who likes you will wait for a plan.
Money, investments and urgent stories
Hinge's scam guidance is plain. Never send money to someone you have matched with, and report anyone who starts talking about investments.
Watch for the version that arrives wrapped in warmth. She mentions a trading tip, a crypto platform, a relative with a medical bill, or a sudden problem with her card. Whatever the story, the answer is no, and the next step is a report from inside the app and an unmatch. You owe her no explanation.
Dodging every plan
A woman who is interested will usually say yes to a short, public first date within a reasonable time.
Be careful with a match who always has a reason. Her camera is broken, her week is crazy, she wants to chat for another two weeks first. Bumble lists the same sign for fake accounts, and it applies here too. Her story keeps changing, and she avoids video calls or meeting.
A short video call before the date settles a lot. If she keeps finding excuses, you have your answer.
Warm, fast and vague
Some accounts are built to be easy to like. She answers instantly, tells you how much she likes you within a day, and gives almost nothing you can check.
Test it with specifics. Ask which part of town she lives in, what she did last weekend, or where she got a coffee she mentioned. A real woman gives small details. A fake one floats above them with answers like "near the city."
Signs on the page itself
Some flags show up before you send a word. A page made of photos from one shoot with no daily life in any of them. Answers that could belong to anyone. No selfie verification badge, which is not proof of a problem, because the badge only shows that the selfie matched her pictures.
Hostility is another. A page that spends its space listing the kinds of men she will not tolerate tells you how the first hour of the date will go. One dry line is nothing. A whole page of them is worth weighing.
What is not a red flag
Men treat a lot of normal things as warnings. Photos with other men are usually friends or a brother. Mentioning an ex once is honesty. A short page from a busy woman is not disinterest. A woman who says she wants something serious is giving you the information you say you want.
A woman who is very attractive is not a flag either. One sign lowers your confidence a little. Several pointing the same way change what you do.
What to do when you spot one
Stop sending personal details. Do not click a link she sends to take you off the app. Do not send money, a code or a photo of a card, whatever the story.
Report her inside Hinge, which takes under a minute and puts the account in front of the human moderation team Hinge says it has. Then unmatch if you like. If you came close to paying, tell a friend. Men who feel embarrassed stay quiet, and that is how the same account reaches the next man.
Your own red flags
A fair test is to run the same checks on yourself. Do your photos show different days, or one afternoon? Do your answers say something specific? Do you push for a plan, or do you let chats drift?
A match is two people reading each other. If you are asking whether she is trustworthy, she is asking the same about you, and a clear page and a quick plan answer it for both of you.
Written by Matthew Stevens, Co-Founder & Head Coach. More than half a decade coaching men across the US and worldwide.
Everything here comes out of real coaching work: the approaches, dates, texts and profiles we go through with the men we coach.