A flirty Tinder line is a short, playful message that teases one thing she chose to show, sent to a match who already swiped right on you. It is light, a little cocky and aimed at her page, never at her body. The borrowed lines from the internet fail because she has read them from other men. A line that could only have been written to her gets a reply.
What flirty actually means in a first message
Men hear flirty and think suggestive. In a first message, flirty means playful. You are not trying to turn her on in a sentence. You are trying to make her smile and give her an easy way to answer.
a dating coach's openers are a good guide. They are short, a bit irreverent and tied to something on her page. He teases and never insults, and he keeps himself in the position of the man doing the choosing without bragging about it.
The three parts of a flirty line
Every message that works has the same three parts.
First, a specific detail she supplied. A claim in her bio, an odd object in the background, a place she is standing in one picture. Second, a light challenge or tease built on that detail. Third, an easy way to reply, such as a question she can answer in a few words or a claim she can push back on.
Leave out any one of them and the line falls flat. A tease with no detail could be pasted into any chat. A detail with no tease is a plain observation. A tease with no easy reply leaves her nothing to do.
Five lines you can adapt
Treat these as shapes, and swap in your own detail.
If she says she has strong opinions about pineapple on pizza: "Strong opinions are fine. I will only be rude if you are wrong."
If one picture shows her holding a summit sign at the end of a hike: "Bold of you to hold that sign like you did not take the shuttle."
If she writes that she is a karaoke legend: "Legend is a big word. What song are you putting on the line?"
If she says she is the worst cook she knows: "Counting on you to burn something so I can look competent."
If she lists a book you have read: "That ending ruined a Sunday for me. Where did you land on it?"
Each one names a single thing, runs a sentence or two and ends on something she can answer without effort.
Where flirty turns into creepy
The line between playful and uncomfortable is mostly about what you are poking at. Tease her claims, her taste and her sense of humor. Leave her body, her job and her past alone.
Two points are worth keeping. Do not fill the message with praise of how attractive she is, since every man does that. And if the tone gets suggestive, leave things to the imagination instead of spelling anything out. A first message that is explicit usually earns an unmatch, even from a woman who might have liked you.
Pet names, compliments on her looks and anything that sounds like a pitch belong in the bin. They sound like a script, and she has seen the script.
The algorithm will not save a weak line
Men sometimes ask whether a certain line makes the app show them more women. Nobody outside Tinder knows its formula, so the answer is that no line works as a trick. What you can reasonably say, following My reading of how these apps behave, is that women who answer and keep chatting show the app a good experience. A line that gets replies is worth more than one that looks clever and gets silence.
So judge a line by one number. Out of ten women, how many wrote back?
What to send after she answers
If she plays along, keep the same tone and keep it short. My texting rules apply here: one or two ideas per message, and no wall of text.
Start mentioning a plan within a few exchanges. My own texts go from first line to her number in four to seven messages. He brings up meeting early, often as a joke or a condition, so the invitation never arrives from nowhere.
If she answers coolly, do not push forward. My rule is not to escalate off a negative. Bring the tone back to light first, then try again.
If she says nothing, one relaxed follow-up a day or two later about a different detail is enough. After that, let the match go.
Written by Matthew Stevens, Co-Founder & Head Coach. More than half a decade coaching men across the US and worldwide.
Everything here comes out of real coaching work: the approaches, dates, texts and profiles we go through with the men we coach.