A man on The League and Bumble at the same time usually feels like the apps are asking him to be two people. One version for the small room, one for the crowd. He cannot keep both going, so he ends up being nobody in particular on either.
The feeling is real. The conclusion is wrong. What the two apps want from you is different presentation. What they should both be getting is the same standard.
Presentation and standards are not the same thing
Presentation is how you come across. Which photo leads, how long the written lines are, how fast you answer, how much you explain about yourself. That genuinely should change from one app to the next, because the rooms are different sizes and the same line reads differently in each.
Your standard is a separate thing. It is who you are trying to meet. Her age, how far away she actually lives, how she spends a normal week, what she is on there for, and the two or three things you will not bend on for anybody.
That list has nothing to do with which icon she arrived through. A woman who is wrong for you on Bumble is still wrong for you on The League. Once you can see the two as separate, the question stops being how to be two men and becomes how to hold one line in two very different rooms.
What volume does to your standard
A mainstream app gives you more people than you can think about. That sounds like it should make you choosier, and for the first week it does.
Then the sorting gets tiring. By the second month you are not applying a standard, you are reacting to whatever the app put in front of you at eleven at night. Some evenings that makes you lax and you answer somebody you have no real interest in. Other evenings it makes you strict for no reason and you skip past a woman you would have liked, because she was the forty-first profile and you were finished.
Neither of those was a decision, and that is the tell. Your standard did not change. Your attention ran out and the inbox took over the job.
What scarcity does to it
The selective apps do the opposite damage. The League, Raya, Luxy and Inner Circle all show you a small pool, and the same faces come round again.
After a slow fortnight on a small app, a profile that does not really fit starts looking better than it did. Not because you changed your mind, but because the alternative is another quiet week. Men who hold a firm line on the crowded app quietly drop it on the small one, and they almost never notice the moment it happened.
So the same man gets pulled in two directions by two apps, and ends up with no consistent answer to the simplest question in his dating life. Who is this actually for.
Why nobody catches the drift
Because it never arrives as a decision. Nobody sits down and lowers his standard. He gets to Thursday, he has had a long week, and he answers the message that was easiest to answer.
Do that eleven times over a couple of months and you have a dating life that looks nothing like the one you would have designed. Every individual step was reasonable. The shape they add up to is not.
Holding one line is administration, not character
This is the part worth being blunt about. Keeping the same standard across two apps is not a matter of discipline or self-knowledge. You already know what you want. You could write it on one side of a page in ten minutes.
What it takes is somebody applying that page every day, at the same level of care, on the crowded app and the quiet one, in a week when work is difficult. That is an operations problem, and operations problems get solved by being somebody's job rather than somebody's intention.
What it looks like when the standard is written down
Our team starts by getting your terms out of your head and onto paper. Age range, real distance, what you want this to turn into, and the handful of things you will not bend on. That page then governs both apps.
The presentation still changes app by app. The photos get ordered differently, the written lines get written differently, and the pace on the small app is slower than the pace on the crowded one. What does not change is who gets your attention. On a heavy week the terms are exactly the same as on a quiet one, because the people applying them are not tired of your dating life.
And when the terms turn out to be wrong, you say so and they get rewritten. That is a different thing from drift. One is a decision, the other is erosion.
The honest version
If you enjoy running your own apps, keep them. Plenty of men do this well and there is nothing here to fix.
If what you want is one standard held steadily, on every app you are on, while your week does whatever your week does, that is not a character flaw to correct. It is work, and work can be handed over.
Our team redoes your photos and your whole profile, runs the apps you are already on, mainstream and selective, and carries the conversations worth carrying until dates are booked. You show up. The promise attached is narrow. Your first date within a week, or we keep working. After that the target is 2-3 dates each week.
If your standard has quietly been two different standards for a while, see if you qualify and we will tell you whether the Online Dating Concierge fits.
Written by Matthew Stevens, Co-Founder & Head Coach. More than half a decade coaching men across the US and worldwide.
Everything here comes out of real coaching work: the approaches, dates, texts and profiles we go through with the men we coach.
More from the library6 related articles
- 01How to Tell Whether the App Is the Problem or You Are5m
- 02What Changes on an Invite Only Dating App When You Stop Running It Yourself5m
- 03Running Raya and Hinge at the Same Time Without Doing It Yourself5m
- 04Should You Mention Your Religion on a Dating Profile5m
- 05Should You Ask Questions or Share Stories When Texting a Match5m
- 06How a Team Chooses Which Photo Leads on Each Dating App5m