Mutual Search shows you members who fit what you are looking for and who are also looking for someone like you. Reverse Search keeps only the second half: it shows members who are looking for someone like you, however well they fit your own preferences. Mutual Search sits on the Search page of the dating site, and Reverse Search gets more accurate the more specifically you describe yourself.
What Mutual Search shows you
Mutual Search is a two-way filter. A woman appears only if she fits what you said you want and you fit what she said she wants.
That makes it the efficient option. Everyone in the results has, on paper, a reason to be glad you wrote. You are not spending your evening on women whose own settings would have ruled you out before they finished reading.
What Reverse Search shows you
Reverse Search looks at only one side, which is her side. It shows women who are looking for someone like you and ignores whether they fit your preferences.
That sounds strange until you try it. Some of the women it shows will be wrong for you, and you skip them. Others will be women you would never have seen, because your own filters quietly hid them.
It is also a useful reminder of where you stand. A list of women who are actively looking for a man like you makes it plain that writing to them is not asking a favor.
Why describing yourself precisely matters
Reverse Search depends on the details you gave about yourself. It can only connect you with women looking for someone like you if Match knows what you are like.
So fill in your own details carefully and honestly. Height, education, whether you want kids, how you feel about drinking and smoking: each one helps Reverse Search place you. Blank or vague answers make the results vaguer too.
Honesty matters here more than anywhere. Round your height up and Reverse Search will introduce you to women expecting a taller man. That is a first date that starts badly before you sit down.
The written parts of your page matter too. Reverse Search may bring her to you, but she still reads what you wrote before she decides to answer.
When to use Mutual Search
Use Mutual Search when you want your time to go furthest. If you have one evening to write to a few women, starting from a list where the interest can run both ways gives each message a better chance.
It is also the better default if you are new to Match. Start with the women who fit on both sides, see how they respond, and learn from what comes back.
When to use Reverse Search
Use Reverse Search when your usual searches feel thin, or when you suspect your filters are too tight.
Men often set preferences that cut out women who would have liked them, and whom they would have liked back. A woman slightly outside your age range, or a little further away than you set, can be a better date than half the women inside it.
The same thing happens from her side. A younger woman might cap her age range and never see you, even though she would have been glad to meet you. Reverse Search helps you find the women on the other side of that problem: the ones who already want what you are.
Read the results with an open mind. You will skip a lot of them. The few who surprise you are the reason to look.
A simple weekly routine
Most men do better with a steady routine than with a burst of effort every few weeks.
Two or three evenings a week, open Mutual Search and write to the three or four women who interest you most. Keep each message short and specific. Once a week, run Reverse Search instead and look for anyone your usual search has been hiding from you.
Then look at who answers. If the Mutual Search women reply and the Reverse Search women rarely do, your settings were probably fine. If Reverse Search keeps turning up women you like, loosen your preferences, because they were costing you good dates.
Turning a search into a date
Neither search does anything until you write to someone.
Pick the women who genuinely interest you and read their pages. Then send a short first message with one specific detail and an easy question. Search is one of Match's real strengths, because you choose who to contact instead of waiting to be shown someone. That strength only pays off if you use it.
Keep both searches in your routine. Use Mutual Search on your regular evenings. Every so often, run Reverse Search to see who you have been filtering out.
Written by Matthew Stevens, Co-Founder & Head Coach. More than half a decade coaching men across the US and worldwide.
Everything here comes out of real coaching work: the approaches, dates, texts and profiles we go through with the men we coach.