No single app is best in Miami for every man, and a list that names one without knowing which part of the city you live in is guessing. Start with Hinge, Tinder and Bumble, run two of them for two weeks with the same photos, and keep the one that gives you more matches, more replies and more plans. Set your distance with the geography in mind, because a date across the bay is a real drive.
Why there is no honest ranking
No app publishes how many people use it in Miami, and our material does not rank apps by city. A Miami top ten you read online was either written years ago or made up, and a user count for any single app in this city is a guess.
a dating coach does say that app choice depends on where you are. In the United States, he says, Hinge tends to be better in a lot of the major cities, in part because of fake accounts on Tinder. In many places in Europe, he says, Tinder is nearly the only app people use. Miami is a major US city, so Hinge is a fair place to begin. But his comparison is a starting point and not a measurement of your city, so test it.
The three to try first
Hinge. a dating coach puts Hinge and Bumble on the relationship side of the spectrum. On Hinge you read a woman's prompt answers and details before you act. Every match begins with a Like on one photo or prompt, so the first message writes itself if you read what she wrote.
Tinder. He says its reputation leans toward hookups, which suits a man open to casual dating, though real relationships begin there as well. If you want something steady, put that on your page in plain words.
Bumble. A match on Bumble waits for the woman to send the first message. Your photos and prompts have to give her a reason to write, and you need to answer her quickly when she does.
Loyalty to one app is not required. a dating coach's advice is to run a few and drop whichever one goes quiet.
A city with water in the middle
Miami is not one tight grid. Miami Beach, Brickell, Wynwood, Coral Gables and the neighborhoods north and south all sit a drive apart. The causeways over Biscayne Bay can turn a short distance on the map into a long trip.
Draw your distance circle too small and you lose women who live twenty minutes away. Draw it too large and you collect matches you will never meet. Begin in the middle, and stretch it only when you keep seeing the same profiles.
a dating coach's rule on logistics matters more in a city like this. He sets a first date near his own home, and if that does not work he goes near hers. A good evening that ends with a forty minute drive back for both of you is a frustrating one, and the second date gets harder to agree to.
Keep the first date simple
He prefers a drink to a dinner. It costs less, it feels more romantic, and if it is going well you can go somewhere else. A long meal commits you to the whole evening before you know whether you want it.
Choose a spot in a part of town you already know, so you can suggest it without hesitating and leave without fuss. A named place on a named evening gets a faster yes than "we should hang out".
Run a small test
Give each app two weeks with the same photos and the same written lines. Keep a tally of women you liked, matches, replies to your first message and dates agreed.
After that, change one thing, usually the lead photo, and tally again. Whichever app produces more dates for the same effort is your app, even if none of your friends use it.
Check who is actually active
A page that looks good can belong to a woman who last opened the app a month ago. Where an app shows when someone was last active, use it, and spend your first messages on women who were on recently. a dating coach's habit of working a batch of matches and then waiting also fits a big city: write to the women you have before you go looking for more.
What matters more than the app
In a big city, a woman on an app may see a lot of men in one evening. What gets you picked out of that is a clear face in daylight, a few shots of a real week, and a first message that mentions something specific from her page.
The men who get dates are rarely the ones who found the perfect app. They are the ones whose photos are clear, whose first line is specific, and who ask for a plan.
Written by Matthew Stevens, Co-Founder & Head Coach. More than half a decade coaching men across the US and worldwide.
Everything here comes out of real coaching work: the approaches, dates, texts and profiles we go through with the men we coach.