The cutest lines are not on any list. A cute opening message is short, warm and about one specific thing she showed you, so she can answer it without effort. The list versions, the "are you a..." jokes and the puns on her name, get a polite silence, because she has read them in other men's messages all week and swiped past them. What you want is a small, friendly remark that only fits her.
What cute means in a first message
On a dating app, cute means a light, warm message to a match. It is not a pickup trick and it does not need to be clever.
A cute message does three things. It shows you looked at her page. It makes a small, harmless joke or a friendly guess. And it ends on something easy to answer, so she does not have to work to reply.
Four examples
These are shapes, not scripts. Swap in the real detail from her page.
- She has a dog in two photos: "I have questions about the dog's chain of command. Who actually runs your house?"
- She wrote that she would eat pasta every night: "Strong claim. I know one place that might actually beat your favorite. Want to hear the name?"
- She has a photo from a trip: "That looks like a trip with a story. Is it the best part you tell people, or the part you leave out?"
- She likes a hobby you do not know: "Okay, I will admit I have no idea how this works. Is it as hard as it looks?"
Each one uses a fact she chose to show. Each one is under twenty words. Each one asks one thing.
The recipe behind a good message
a dating coach's first-message method starts the same way: read her page and look for anything unusual you can comment on, ideally something you can tease a little. Two rules from him are worth keeping. Shorter is better, and it is usually better to comment on one of her written answers than on a photo, because a written answer reads as more genuine and less about her looks.
So the steps are simple. Find the one detail. Say one friendly thing about it. Ask one question. Stop.
Messages to leave out
A few things turn a cute message into a worse one.
- A compliment on her body or her face in the first line. She has had a hundred, and the next one costs you.
- Any line that works on anyone. If the message could go to the last five women you matched with, it is a line, and she will treat it as one.
- A pun on her name, an "are you a..." setup or a joke built to get a laugh out of her. It reads as trying.
- A bare "hey". It is easy, but it asks her to do all the work.
Can you reuse a message with other matches
Yes, with care. coach is relaxed about stock material. His approach is to keep a message that worked on a certain kind of woman and send it again to the same kind. The condition is that it is about something she did, so it still feels personal.
The test is whether you would be comfortable saying it out loud. If you would not, do not send it. A line you borrowed and do not believe in sounds off, and it gives you nothing to say when she answers.
What a reply does for the algorithm, and what comes next
A cute message earns a reply. It does not earn a date. a dating coach's reading is that replies count as engagement, so the app's algorithm tends to show you to more women. Once she answers, keep your replies about as long as hers, and ask one thing at a time. When there is some warmth in the conversation, suggest a simple, specific plan, such as a drink on a particular evening.
If you send cute messages and none get answered, look at your photos first. A message cannot rescue a first photo that put her off. If the photos are fine, shorten your message, count your replies over a week, and change one thing at a time.
Written by Matthew Stevens, Co-Founder & Head Coach. More than half a decade coaching men across the US and worldwide.
Everything here comes out of real coaching work: the approaches, dates, texts and profiles we go through with the men we coach.