You added the second app because the first one had gone quiet, and within a fortnight the apps had quietly taken over your evenings. Most men blame the extra account. The extra account is not what did it.
The swiping was never the expensive part
Sit down and swipe properly through forty profiles and it takes six or seven minutes. Do that on two apps and you have spent about a quarter of an hour. Nobody's week is ruined by a quarter of an hour.
What actually costs you is the checking. The app gets opened on the walk to the station, at your desk, in the queue for coffee, on the sofa during the adverts, and once more in bed. Each open is thirty seconds of looking and then ten minutes of being half in a conversation you are not really having.
Fifteen of those a day on one app is already a lot. Add a second account and you are now doing thirty. That is the doubling men feel, and it has almost nothing to do with swiping.
What all that checking buys you
Very little. Answering a woman at four minutes past eleven instead of on the hour changes nothing about whether she comes for a drink.
What does matter is answering the same day, and not letting a conversation that was going well sit untouched for three days. Both of those are easily done from one sitting.
There is a cost to constant checking that men miss, too. Messages written while you are walking, or standing in a queue, or half watching something, are short and flat, because you were not really there when you wrote them. You end up sending your worst material the most often.
One sitting a day, both apps, in that order
Pick a time you are reliably free and give it twenty to twenty five minutes. Evening is best, because that is when women are actually on the apps and answering.
Work in a fixed order.
Answer messages first, on both apps, before you look at anything else. This is the only part with a clock on it. Conversations cool, women get asked out by someone else, and a reply that comes tomorrow is a different reply.
Then deal with your likes and matches, so nothing sits unopened for a week looking like you could not be bothered.
Then swipe last, and stop when you notice you are no longer reading profiles. The last ten minutes of any swiping session is not a decision, it is a habit.
Then close both apps and leave them closed until tomorrow.
One profile, not two
The most common mistake with a second app is building a second man. New photos in a different order, a bio written in a different mood, a version of you that is slightly more serious or slightly more of a joker.
If a photo set works, it works everywhere. Use the same photographs in the same order on both accounts. Your best photo is your best photo on either platform.
The written part has to be rewritten, because the apps ask for it differently. One wants three short prompt answers and another wants a paragraph. Rewrite the words to fit the box, not the substance. The same three things about you should come through on both.
Keeping two different profiles has a second cost. When one account does better than the other, you cannot tell whether it was the app or the profile, because you changed both at once.
What is worth setting differently on each
Two things, and only two.
Distance, because the pools are not the same size. The app with fewer people near you gets the wider radius. That is usually the whole reason it felt dead.
Age range, if one platform genuinely skews younger or older where you live. Set it by who is actually showing up rather than by habit.
Everything else stays matched. If you want to test whether a different first photo does better, change it on one app only and leave it alone for two weeks. Change three things at once and you have learned nothing.
When a second app earns its place
There are two good reasons to be on two.
The first is that you have got to the end of the queue on your main app and there is nobody new to see. A second platform is simply more people.
The second is that the women on your main app are not the ones you want. Apps cluster differently in most cities, and moving platform can change who you are looking at more than anything you do to your profile.
There is one bad reason, and it is the common one. Results are slow, and adding an account feels like taking action. If both accounts carry the same photographs and the same profile, a second app buys you the same outcome twice.
When one sitting a day is more than you actually have
Here is the version of this that most men are living. The profile is average rather than bad, the twenty five minutes exist on paper and not in practice, and the apps get a proper look on a Sunday and a handful of distracted glances the rest of the week. Two accounts do not make that worse. They make it obvious.
That is the case where handing the whole operation over does more than any schedule will. One team rebuilds the photos and the profile once, runs every app you want to be on, answers while conversations are still warm, and works the promising ones toward a date on your calendar. Both accounts get run properly every day, by someone whose job it is, and you show up to the drink.
If the twenty five minutes are genuinely there, use them in one block and you can run two apps on less attention than you are currently giving one. If they are not there, the number of apps was never the problem.
Written by Matthew Stevens, Co-Founder & Head Coach. More than half a decade coaching men across the US and worldwide.
Everything here comes out of real coaching work: the approaches, dates, texts and profiles we go through with the men we coach.
More from the library6 related articles
- 01How to Run Your Apps in Twenty Minutes a Day5m
- 02What You Do With the Evening You Used to Spend Swiping5m
- 03How to Stay Consistent on Dating Apps Without Burning Out5m
- 04How to Stop Checking the App Every Ten Minutes4m
- 05Your Week Before and After You Stop Swiping Yourself5m
- 06What a Matchmaker Does and What a Dating Apps Team Does5m