Reply warmly, give her something concrete to say yes to, and follow up lightly once. If she still doesn't commit after two or three tries in total, move on. "I'll let you know" isn't always a no, but it isn't a plan either, and you don't need to wait around for one.
What "I'll let you know" usually means
It can mean several things, and you can't tell which from the words alone.
- She's busy. It doesn't necessarily mean she doesn't like you or isn't interested. Work, family and schedules get in the way, and some people simply forget.
- She's stalling. In one forum thread, posters read it as a soft no with a small chance of a yes. One guessed she hasn't figured out how to say no yet.
- She wants it to be easy. Vague answers are easier than honest ones for a lot of people.
Tone matters. A smile and a "this week is crazy, but I'd like to" is not the same as a flat "I'll let you know." If she repeats it again and again, take it as a sign she isn't interested.
What to say right now
Don't push for an answer on the spot. Reply in a way that keeps it light and gives her an easy next step.
- "Sounds good. If you're free this week, Thursday or Friday works for me."
- "No worries. If you want to grab a drink, let me know by Thursday."
- "Sounds good. If this week's too busy, we can do next week instead."
A specific option beats a vague "sometime." It's easy to say yes to a plan and hard to say yes to nothing.
If she doesn't get back to you
Wait a day or two. Then send one short message:
- "Hey, still up for that drink? Thursday or Saturday works for me."
- "No pressure. If your week got busy, we can do next week."
If she replies with a day, lock it in with a time and a place. If she says she's slammed, answer once with "No problem, hit me when your schedule opens up" and leave the next move to her.
If she doesn't reply to that, stop after two or three attempts in total and put your energy elsewhere.
What not to do
- Don't send a reminder text a few hours later. It looks pushy.
- Don't double-text. One message, then wait.
- Don't try to punish her by waiting to reply to her. It makes you look worse.
- Don't send "Did I do something wrong?" or "I guess you don't care." That's panic, and it makes the next message harder for her to answer.
- Don't stay in the reply loop. If she cancels three times and never offers a new time, you aren't missing a clue. You're on the bench.
If the delays keep happening and you do like her, you can say it plainly once: "It's hurtful when you take so long to reply to me." Say it only once, and be ready to walk away if nothing changes.
Persistence that works vs. pressure
There's a real difference. Persistence is brief, steady and tied to a clear question. Pressure is repeated, emotional and tied to your need for an answer.
Good persistence sounds like this:
- "I'd like to see you Friday. If not, another time works."
- "If you're not interested, just say so."
Bad persistence sounds like three follow-ups in six hours.
People meet you halfway when you seem grounded. If you look like you need the answer to feel okay, the whole thing gets heavier than it has to be.
What to persist through, and what to stop at
Dating is uncomfortable, and some awkwardness is normal. Keep going through:
- A little hesitation
- A busy week
- "I'm bad at texting, but I do want to see you." That's workable. Offer a call or a plan.
Stop at:
- A clear no
- Repeated cancellations with no new time offered
- Mixed signals that never become action
- Anger when you ask for a simple answer
A rule that keeps you out of trouble
Ask once, follow up lightly, then let the silence answer for you. A woman who's interested will meet the effort. If she isn't, more messages won't create desire. They'll just create noise.
Insist on a clear answer, not on a yes.
Written by Matthew Stevens, Co-Founder & Head Coach. More than half a decade coaching men across the US and worldwide.
Everything here comes out of real coaching work: the approaches, dates, texts and profiles we go through with the men we coach.




















