Most Compatible is the recommendation Hinge believes you are most likely to connect with. When one is available, it sits at the top of your Discover feed. Hinge says the pick is based on mutual preferences, your recent activity, and the overlap between who you tend to like and who other daters tend to like. Each suggestion expires after 24 hours.
Where it shows up
Open Discover on a day when Hinge has a pick for you, and she is the first person you see. Hinge says it tries to send a new one each day.
The 24-hour limit is the part that catches men out. The help page closes with a plain nudge: if someone catches your eye, do not wait too long to send a like. A pick you look at on Tuesday and mean to come back to on Thursday will have expired long before you get there.
What the pick is built from
Hinge names three inputs, and each one tells you something about how to read the pick.
Mutual preferences come first. Hinge's Discover feed as a whole is built on mutual interest: the people you see fit your preferences, and you fit theirs. Most Compatible rests on mutual preferences too. So the pick is not simply the woman you would rate highest. It is someone Hinge expects to be interested back.
Recent activity is the second input. What you have been doing in the app lately is part of the calculation, so the pick follows your behavior and not only the settings you chose on the first day.
The third input is shared taste. Hinge looks at who you tend to like, compares it with who other daters tend to like, and uses the overlap to make its guess.
How much weight to give it
Treat it as an informed guess and nothing grander. Hinge's mission page describes these suggestions as the people you are most likely to have mutual chemistry with. That gives you a head start on a likely fit. She still has to like what she sees when your like arrives.
So the useful way to think of the pick is as the one page each day that deserves your full attention. It is not a sign, and it is not the only woman worth liking that day.
How to like her well
Read her whole page before you decide. The later photos and the prompts tell you far more than the first photo, and they hand you something to say.
Then like a specific photo or prompt and add a comment. Hinge's Discover page says adding a comment makes a like more likely to get a response. Make it about something on her page: a playful guess about her, a light tease, or a question only she could answer.
"You look like someone with firm opinions on the right way to load a dishwasher" gives her a reason to reply. "Hey, you're cute" gives her nothing to work with, and she has read it plenty of times before.
When to pass
You do not owe the pick a like. If you read her page and would not actually take her out, skip her.
Liking women you feel lukewarm about only fills your Matches with conversations you will let die. It also muddies the one input you fully control, since your recent activity is part of what the next pick is built from.
Getting better picks over time
Two of the three inputs are yours to shape.
Set your preferences to the women you would really date, rather than widening them out of boredom or narrowing them out of nerves. Then use the app the way you want to be read: like the women you would take out, and give each page an honest look before you skip it.
The third input, the overlap with other daters' taste, you cannot steer at all. That is a good reason not to overthink any single pick.
After she likes you back
The pick gets you as far as a match. Everything after that is the ordinary work of turning a match into a date.
Reply while the match is fresh. Keep your early messages light and about her, not a list of facts about you. Once she is answering warmly and quickly, suggest a plan. The timing rule is simple: ask as soon as she is ready and no sooner. Push before then and it reads as pressure. Wait much longer and the conversation drifts into small talk that goes nowhere.
Written by Matthew Stevens, Co-Founder & Head Coach. More than half a decade coaching men across the US and worldwide.
Everything here comes out of real coaching work: the approaches, dates, texts and profiles we go through with the men we coach.