Look at her face before you answer. If she is smiling and leaning in, she is probably playing with you, and a relaxed, playful "maybe, is it working?" is a good reply. If she looks uneasy or her voice is flat, she may be checking whether she needs to set a boundary, and the right move is a calm, honest answer and a step back. Do not panic, do not deny it in a rush, and do not make it a big speech.
Why she asks
Women ask this for a few different reasons, and the reason decides your answer.
She might be having fun. A smiling "are you flirting with me?" is often a way of keeping the game going. She is saying she noticed, and she wants to see what you do.
She might be unsure. She cannot tell whether you are being friendly or interested, and she wants to know where she stands.
She might be uncomfortable. If you have been making comments she did not invite, or she did not expect attention from you, the question can be a polite way of asking you to stop.
The words are the same in all three. The tone and her body language are not.
If she is smiling and playing
This is the best case. Stay light and do not get nervous. A few answers that work:
"A little. Is it working?"
"Only if it is going well."
"I was trying to be subtle. Clearly I failed."
"Maybe. What gave me away?"
These answers admit what is happening without sounding needy. They keep the playful energy. And they hand the choice back to her with a smile.
Notice what they do not do: they do not deny it, and they do not apologize. Backing off with "no, no, I was just being friendly" kills the mood and can make you seem like you are afraid of your own interest.
After you answer, follow it with a small step. If it is going well, ask a question about her or suggest a plan. "Good. So when are you free for a drink?" turns the banter into something real.
If she is unsure
When she looks curious but not clearly happy, give a calm and honest answer. You do not need to hide your interest, and you do not need to push it either.
"I enjoy talking to you, so yes, a bit. Is that okay?"
Asking if it is okay is not weak. It tells her you will respect her answer, which makes a woman feel safe and makes her more likely to say yes.
If she looks uncomfortable
If her answer comes with a flat voice, folded arms, a step back or a glance toward the door, treat the question as a boundary.
Say something short and kind:
"Sorry, I did not mean to make you uncomfortable. I will leave it there."
Then do exactly that. Change the subject or end the conversation politely. Do not argue, do not explain how nice you are, and do not ask whether she is sure.
If you are at work or in a place where you will see her again, this matters even more. Respecting the line quickly keeps things professional and protects your reputation.
What not to say
Some answers make things worse in every case:
- "No, I was just being nice." If you were flirting, this is a lie, and she can usually tell.
- "Why, are you flirting with me?" Bouncing it back can sound defensive.
- "Would it be a problem if I was?" In a tense moment this reads as pressure.
- A long explanation of your feelings. She asked a short question.
- Anger or sarcasm if she says no.
What if she says "you can flirt with me" or "go ahead and flirt"
Some searches around this question come from the opposite situation, where she invites it. If a woman says "will you flirt with me?" or "you can flirt with me," she is giving you clear permission and a lot of confidence. Do not go blank.
Keep it playful. "I will try. Fair warning, I am better at it after dinner." Then follow through with a tease, a compliment or a plan. She has opened the door, so walk through it with warmth and good humor.
What this question tells you either way
A woman who asks "are you flirting with me?" is paying attention to you. That is useful information even when the answer is not what you hoped for.
If she smiles, you are in a good spot. If she is unsure, your calm answer can make her feel at ease. If she is uncomfortable, a graceful exit is a better result than an awkward argument.
Treat each case honestly and you will usually leave the conversation with her respect intact, and that is the best base for any later connection.
Written by Matthew Stevens, Co-Founder & Head Coach. More than half a decade coaching men across the US and worldwide.
Everything here comes out of real coaching work: the approaches, dates, texts and profiles we go through with the men we coach.