Early dating should feel mostly fun and easy, with a little nervous energy. You enjoy her company and the conversation goes both ways. Plans get made without a negotiation, and you are curious about her instead of afraid of losing her. If you spend most of your time decoding her texts, rehearsing what to say, or feeling a knot in your stomach, something is out of balance. Usually you are investing faster than the information you have justifies.
What a good early stretch feels like
You can picture an ordinary week. Rather than being sure about her, you only need to notice the following:
- You look forward to seeing her and you feel better afterward than before.
- The talk flows. You do not have to perform.
- She answers, asks you things, and sometimes starts a conversation herself.
- A plan takes one or two messages, not a week of "we should do something."
- When a day passes without contact, you are fine.
- You have a life of your own that keeps going.
You will also feel some nerves before a date and some butterflies when you kiss her. Nervous excitement is normal. Dread is different.
What a bad early stretch feels like
These are the signs that you should slow down or look at what is happening:
- You analyze every reply for hidden meaning.
- You are the one who always suggests the plan.
- You feel relieved, not happy, when she texts.
- You keep adjusting yourself so she will like you.
- You feel drained after seeing her, or you cannot sleep when she is quiet.
- You are already planning the future with someone you have met three times.
You are spending more than you have been given, and that does not make her wrong for you.
Why does early dating hurt so much?
Men ask why it hurts so much in the first weeks, and the answer is usually one of two things.
The first is a gap between what you know and what you hope. You have met her a few times. You know almost nothing about her. But your mind has already filled in the rest, and that imagined person can disappoint you without doing anything wrong.
The second is pressure. coach says the goal of dating should not be to find your next girlfriend. It should be to have a good dating life, and a girlfriend can come out of that. If you treat every date as an audition for the role, you pile pressure on yourself, on her and on the evening. That pressure makes you needier and less fun, and it lowers your chances.
A polite "I had a nice time, but I don't feel it" hurts far more when you have spent three weeks picturing a future with her. The hurt is the size of the hope you built.
Keep the hope the size of the facts
Match your investment to what has actually happened. After one date, you have one date. You can like her and still not know whether you want to be with her, and she is doing the same sum about you.
A few ways to do that:
- Keep seeing your friends and training. Your week should not rearrange around her reply.
- Do not define the relationship early. coach points out that relationships tend to drift gradually toward the right arrangement for the two people, and that you do not need an answer in week two.
- Keep dating normal. If you are seeing a couple of women, that is fine until you both say otherwise.
- Look at her actions. A woman who is interested books time with you. Words and compliments mean less than that.
When it really is a warning
Some feelings are a warning and not just nerves. Pay attention if she is hot and cold in a way that leaves you guessing. Pay attention if she cancels often and never offers another day. And pay attention if she makes you feel small or anxious around her most of the time.
In those cases, do not try harder. A woman who is into you makes the early days simple, so if they are hard, believe the signal and spend your effort on someone else.
A quick check
At the end of a date, ask yourself two things. Did I enjoy myself? Do I want to see her again? If both are yes, keep going and let the rest sort itself out slowly. If the first is no, you have your answer, and it is okay to say so kindly.
Written by Matthew Stevens, Co-Founder & Head Coach. More than half a decade coaching men across the US and worldwide.
Everything here comes out of real coaching work: the approaches, dates, texts and profiles we go through with the men we coach.